Darksiders II and Zelda TP Dungeon Progression Comparisons Pt. 1

An info graghic displaying the progression of Drenchfort and the Forest Temple from Darksiders 2 and Zelda Twilight Princess
(Right Click -> View Image in order to see at full resolution)

Original design plans for Atrophy placed it in the adventure genre, mixing combat with puzzles to create a fluid experience.  As the level designer, I wanted to find a decent flow or progression to the level.  How much combat should there be versus puzzles?  I decided it best to look at several levels from some popular adventure games.

Zelda was an original inspiration for Atrophy and a common series played by most of the design team.  Twilight Princess was one of my favorites regarding theme and visuals.  I decided to analyze the first dungeon, the Forest Temple.

I wanted to cross reference Zelda TP against another series in the genre though in order to get a better perspective of pacing.  I was currently playing the Darksiders series- riding the high from completing the first game, and really enjoying the second one.  The Darksiders series holds a lot of similarities to the Zelda franchise.  Both are adventure games with similar level designs, but Darksider’s combat is more ferocious akin to God of War 3 while Zelda has stuck to it’s slower but more calculated fighting.

Drenchfort is the 2nd dungeon, but the pistol awarded from the previous dungeon opened up ranged puzzles similar to the Forest Temple in Zelda TP.  Measuring as similar an experience from each game was important.

I watched 100% playthroughs of each dungeon from YouTube.  Links below.  These players knew exactly what to do and did not waste unnecessary time in unimportant areas.  This may skew the average player experience, but I set this as my standard in order to accurately measure between the two games.  I then recorded how long each action was performed and created the image above with an overview of the dungeons progression.

Zelda Twilight Princess – Forest Temple
Darksiders II – Drenchfort

Atrophy ended up going a different direction and I never got to fully utilize the information I gathered, but I post it here now for anyone who might find it useful.  In my next post, I will break down the information in the image and what can be learned from it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s